The Downsides Of Incompatible Greases
Recently, I have come across a plethora of questions regarding grease. Generally, the theme of most of them is, “why can I not use synthetic grease from the local parts store in my aircraft?”
Today, synthetic lubricants are one of
the present ‘buzz’ or ‘now’ words. If a lubricant has the word ‘synthetic’ with
it, people expect it to last forever, lubricating anything and everything
presented to it.
While synthetic-based oils provide
certain advantages, especially in extreme low or high temperatures, they aren’t
the cure-all, end-all that people are hoping for.
Basically, grease isn’t a thick oil.
It’s regular oil base stocks that are thickened using chemicals.
The thickening agent varies based on
base oil and usage. This is crucial to this question because not every
thickening agent is compatible.
If you buy a grease that isn’t compatible with the grease
already in the bearing, you can end up with a soup-like substance that will
leak out of the seals, exposing the bearings.
One of our clients said he planned to
clean the bearings and start with all new grease. While this limits the
compatibility problem now, what will happen when he puts the aircraft for sale a
few years down the line? Will the new owner have a failure after he tries to
revert back to the proper grease?
This is why it is important for pilots
to do their homework when purchasing a used aircraft. It is recommended that
they always check the maintenance records to ensure that the previous owner
properly lubricated the aircraft at the appropriate intervals, using the
recommended spec grease. If not, you may have to start over with the correct
product after thoroughly cleaning the bearings.
The seal compatibility is another
major problem with non-aviation lubricants. Numerous synthetic greases will
shrink seals that are meant for only mineral oils. This shrinkage can allow
dirt and water to enter the bearing area, grease to leak out, and substantially
reduce the life of the bearing.
The centrifugal force is the third
major problem, especially with synthetic greases.
Several years ago, a major
company wanted to change the spec for the
grease used in its props. Traditionally, the company has utilized a grease-like
Aeroshell grease 5 in the props. However, this product was based on thick
mineral oil and was a bit stiff for certain lubricant applications, especially
at high altitudes.
The company tried numerous synthetic
products, but each of them seemed to have a problem. That is because synthetic
base oils are excellent lubricants, but average solvents. Under high
centrifugal forces, this led to the thickeners being separated from the base
stocks. The thin base oils leaked all over the exterior of the prop after the
thickeners plugged it up.
The bottom line? In an aircraft, there
are a ton of technical reasons why you need to stick to only those products
that qualify for your application.
While we’re all aware that general-purpose
greases seem to meet the same specs as the mil-spec for products that qualify
for your aircraft, but many differences can make a substantial difference in
the safety and performance of your aircraft.
Comments
Post a Comment